|
The
principal attorney in our law firm, William A.
Cohn, has over 25 years of experience in
Bankruptcy.
Chapter 13 - Wage Earner Plan/For
persons who earn wages, for small business owners,
and for individuals who have a source of income.
I. FEES AND COSTS
COST:
$250.00 DOWN to cover filing fees, photocopies,
postage, check handling, etc.
PLUS:
Attorney Fee Retainer $500.00
***The balance is part of the money
deducted from your paycheck
An attorney fee of $2,400.00 is set
by the Court in a Chapter 13 case. Your payment of $500.00 is
applied to the $2,400.00 awarded, and the balance is paid as
part of the money deducted from your payment of the plan. The Court
can award additional fees upon the request of the lawyer.
Talk
to a lawyer, not a paralegal. Call us for a free appointment to discuss
your situation.
We do NOT recommend Chapter 13.
Only about 35% of Chapter 13
plans payout. Clients have over the years
routinely complained that they go to Court many
times and are
always having their
payments raised by the Chapter
13 Trustee. As lawyers, we have no control
over payments. The Chapter 13 Trustee uses
his computer at the Creditors' Meeting and tells
the client and the lawyers the payment amount and
schedule. Very often the Chapter 13 Trustees later
advise that the debtor has not paid enough in and
the payments must be raised.
Lawyers' fees have
routinely been substantially underpaid in relation to non
bankruptcy areas of law (even though the
Bankruptcy Code forbids this). In fact, Lawyers are
usually actually paid only about 1/3 of what the Court
"awards." Do you think that this would lead to good
representation in Chapter 13 cases?
There are absolutely no heads of any large law firms
that appear in Bankruptcy Court on Chapter 13 cases. Usually,
the low man on the totem pole in the law firm is sent. Far
too much negotiation results. To make matters worse, very few debtors
who file Chapter 13 know: the amount of the lawyers'
fees, the filing fees, the trustees' fees, and creditors'
lawyers fees. Neither the judges nor the trustees tell
the amount to the debtors if their lawyers do not. The judges
have a great many cases and do not even personally
sign all of their own Orders.
At least one
judge, Judge Jennie Latta, to her credit, has openly attempted
to improve the quality of the law practice in her court.
However, the principal lawyer in this firm has, in the
past, routinely encountered an unwillingness of the
Bankruptcy Court judges and personnel and appointees to
seriously consider changes consistent with their policies.
As a client, does this assure you that your interests are properly litigated?
We therefore only recommend Chapter 13
as a last resort. Only if you
are several months behind on your car note or house
note and cannot bring the note current prior to
filing, do we recommend Chapter 13. A BETTER ALTERNATIVE:
We recommend that you file a Chapter 7. We do not
agree that there is a moral or ethical basis to have you re
pay your debts if you are not able to do so, if your efforts
to do so are proving fruitless, or if your financial condition
is causing family or marital problems. Our experience is
that more marital problems are caused by financial burdens
than any other basis. Your marital relationship
and your family's health are far more important
than re paying your debts in whole or in part.
Chapter 13 is nothing more
than an additional payment burden for up to 5 years. Chapter
7 is usually over in 4 to 6 months. If a creditor files
an objection to discharge and asks that its debt not be wiped out,
you still wipe out all of your other debts in 4 to 6 months, with
far fewer total court appearances than in Chapter 13. Chapter
7 saves you money, stress, and time.
Call
901-757-5557 for a free appointment to discuss your situation.
II. SECURED DEBT vs. UNSECURED
DEBT
A.
Secured debt is a debt where the Creditor can take
back, repossess, or foreclose an item in
satisfaction of his debt. In other words, a
mortgage company can foreclose on your house; a
bank or finance company can repossess your car or
household goods; a furniture sales company can take
your furniture back; or a jewelry store can take
back your jewelry. Where the Creditor extends to
you the credit to make the purchase for consumer
goods, that is a secured debt also.
B. An
unsecured debt is a debt where a creditor cannot
repossess an item or foreclose on any item.
Examples of this type of debt are: Credit cards,
such as Master Card, VISA, and American Express;
Signature Loans; Deficiencies on Cars that have
been repossessed or houses that have been
foreclosed; doctor bills, hospital bills, lawyer
bills; and suppliers of small businesses that do
not have a security interest in the goods.
CHAPTER 13 . . . (Wage Earner)
Bankruptcy
A
Chapter 13 bankruptcy used to be called a "Wage
Earner" plan. It is a type of bankruptcy where you
pay out your debts.
A
Chapter 13 Plan is like a consolidation loan at a
bank. In a consolidation loan, you borrow the money
from the bank, you pay off your creditors all at
once , and you pay the bank back each month at
$100.00/$200.00/$300.00 per month or whatever the
amount necessary to pay off the loan.
In the
Chapter 13 plan the Chapter 13 Trustee is the bank.
You pay your $100.00/200.00/300.00 or whatever the
amount to the Chapter 13 Trustee each month. He
takes each payment and divides it up and pays your
creditors. Secured creditors get 100 cents on the
dollar plus interest. Unsecured creditors also get
100 cents on the dollar, unless we can show that
because of the amount of income and expenses you
cannot fund a Chapter 13 plan sufficiently to pay
out 100 cents on the dollar. In that case the
unsecured creditors may get less than 100 cents on
the dollar: 70%..50%.. or even 10 cents on the
dollar. There is an automatic injunction when you
file your Chapter 13 which stops any creditor from
suing you, from issuing a garnishment against you,
from repossessing your car, from foreclosing on
your house, or from doing any other act to collect
the debt. This automatic injunction is what makes
the Chapter 13 plan work by keeping the creditors
away from the debtor.
If your property (such
as a car) was repossessed before the filing of your Chapter 13,
we can ask the Court to Order the creditor to return the property
to you. It will take 3 to 4 weeks to obtain possession of your car,
and you will probably have to pay repossession and storage fees
which have accumulated to regain the vehicle.
Call
901-757-5557 for a free appointment to discuss your situation.
V. THE AUTOMATIC
INJUNCTION
The
automatic injunction is in effect on all
bankruptcies. Anytime you file a petition for
relief in the Bankruptcy Court, there is an
automatic injunction preventing any creditor from
doing anything to collect a debt.
VI. TYPICAL
RECOMMENDATIONS
Typically, we see two situations
develop in Consumer Bankruptcies.
A. The
first situation is where a client has secured debts
in which he is current or only one or two months
behind. In other words, he may be one or two months
behind on his house note, one or two months behind
on his car note, and the same for his furniture and
jewelry note. However, he comes to us and says "I
have been sick and I have a tremendous amount of
medical bills (unsecured debt)"; or "I'm going
through a divorce (or some sort of domestic
problem); and I am at my limit on all my credit
cards and I owe a tremendous amount" (of unsecured
debt). He says if he just didn't have all of this
unsecured debt and that if he wasn't making monthly
payments on this unsecured debt, then he would be
able to make his payments on his secured debt. In
that instance, we recommend a Chapter 7 straight
bankruptcy because he is able to discharge all of
the unsecured debts and obtain a "Fresh Start".
After reaffirmation of this debt and payment of
delinquent installments, he can easily keep up his
monthly notes.
B. The
other situation is where the client arrives and
states that he is three or more months behind on
his house note, three or four months behind on his
car note, several months behind on his jewelry and
furniture note, and that even if he discharged all
of his unsecured debts he still would not be able
to bring his secured debts current. He may not even
have any unsecured debt. However, he does not wish
to lose his assets, but merely needs time to pay
off any arrearages that he owes. This person is a
candidate for a Chapter 13 wage earner plan. It
allows him to pay off his debts and to preserve his
assets. That is our recommendation in such a
circumstance.
C.
There is a gray area in between the two
recommendations. Many people also feel that they
have a moral and ethical obligation to pay out
their debts. In those circumstances, a Chapter 13
(Wage Earner) Plan would be our recommendation. In
the gray areas, it is largely a decision of the
client.
D. If the Bankruptcy
Chapter that you choose does not work out, you may be able to convert
to another Chapter. You have the absolute right to dismiss a Chapter
13, or to convert a Chapter 13 to a Chapter 7.
Call
901-757-5557 for a free appointment to discuss your situation.
VII. STUDENT LOANS
Government issued student loans are
not dischargeable, unless there is a hardship acceptable
to the Court. The debtor must file a complaint for a
hardship discharge. This is not a part of a simple
Bankruptcy filing. The Bankruptcy Court will generally
not grant this petition unless the debtor is elderly and
disabled, penniless, and unable to earn sufficient income to
pay the debt. Does this appear too restrictive? It
certainly is a very conservative interpretation of the
law.
VIII. TAXES
Generally, taxes cannot be
discharged in a Chapter 7 straight
bankruptcy.
However, under certain limited
circumstances, Federal Income tax can be discharged
in bankruptcy if they are more than three calendar
years old, all tax returns have been timely filed,
and the tax has not been assessed by the IRS within
the 9 months before the filing of the Bankruptcy
petition. Liens placed by the IRS can also prevent
discharge. You need to consult with the attorney if
this is a problem.
Obviously, taxes CAN be paid out in
a Chapter 13 wage earner plan and the IRS can be
stopped from enforcing any liens or other
collection procedures by the filing of the Chapter
13 Wage Earner Plan.
A
complaint to determine the dischargeability should
be filed. This is not a part of the simple
Bankruptcy filing.
IX. BANK ACCOUNTS
Any
time you file a bankruptcy, if you have a checking
or savings account or any other kind of deposit
account with a bank to whom you owe any money for a
loan or credit card or other matter, then you
should close out your checking and savings account
and certificate of deposit or any other account
that you have, and move it to a bank to whom you
owe NO money. This will prevent that bank from
obtaining a set-off of your funds.
XII. ADVERSE SITUATIONS
Call 901-757-5557
for a free appointment to discuss your situation.
Chapter 7 discharge can be denied
by the Court under certain circumstances such as
concealing property, destroying or falsifying
records, or fraud. These also can be criminal
matters.
A
discharge under Chapter 7 can also be denied as to
specific debts when a creditor files an "Objection
to Discharge." Only that creditor's debt or a
portion of that debt may be kept from being "wiped
out." Examples are certain taxes, support, loans
obtained by false financial statements or by fraud,
and loans obtained when you are insolvent ( that
is, when you borrow money by loan or by credit card
and your debts exceed your assets-at the time of
the loan-, and you are unable to repay the money
borrowed).
A
Chapter 7 should not be filed before a divorce is
finalized.
A
proposed Chapter 13 Plan can be denied confirmation
(approval by the Court) if the Court, after a
hearing, feels the proposed plan to be unfeasible
(not enough available income to fund the plan), not
proposed in good faith, or not paying the correct
amounts according to the law.
A proposed Chapter 11
Plan can be denied confirmation if not approved by vote of the creditors,
or if it fails to meet certain guidelines required by law.
XIII. MISCELLANEOUS
A
Bankruptcy will stay on your credit record from the
time of filing until the credit reporting agency's
roll over period. This is usually eight years, and
can be as much as 10 years.
There are always other circumstances that need to
be addressed and questions that need to be
answered. Please feel free to ask the lawyer what
happens in these circumstances.
WILLIAM A. COHN
Member: American Bar Association
Member: Commercial Law League of
America
Author
of: "Deferring Vesting of Property in a Chapter 13
Wage Earner Plan"
Commercial Law Journal (August,
1983).
WHAT HAPPENS AFTER FILING CHAPTER
13?
(PLEASE READ THIS AND YOUR
INFORMATION SHEET BEFORE CALLING YOUR
ATTORNEY)
I. The filing of
a Chapter 13 Plan constitutes an automatic
injunction against any creditor to collect any
debt.
A. If you are called
by a creditor or collection agency before the filing of the
Chapter 13 Plan, merely tell them that THE COHN LAW FIRM represents
you and that we are filing a Chapter 13 plan for you and that they
should direct all calls to our office and not call you anymore.
B. Approximately five
days after your interview in our office where you have signed all
of your petitions and documentation to be filed in Court you should
call our office to obtain your bankruptcy number. This is the number
that the Court uses and is called a DOCKET NUMBER. If any
creditor or collection agency calls you or any one has threatened
to repossess your car or has started foreclosure proceedings you
should call this creditor and tell them the bankruptcy number. Also
inform them if they start to question you, that ALL communication
is to be through your attorney THE COHN LAW FIRM in as much we have
instructed you to do so.
C.
Additionally, once we have filed the Chapter 13
plan and you have obtained your bankruptcy number
from us, if you want a payroll deduction and have a
garnishment about to be placed or it has been
placed on your wages, you should inform your
employer immediately of the bankruptcy number and
the type of bankruptcy and that they should contact
our office for further information if they need it.
They should also contact their lawyer if they have
any questions. In any event, they are prohibited
from honoring any garnishment on your wages once
the Chapter 13 petition is filed. The same applies
to any sheriff appearing to repossess any car or
any other item such as a car. Merely tell them the
bankruptcy number and the attorney's name and he
should be aware of the automatic injunction
preventing him from collecting this debt or doing
anything attempting to collect this debt.
D. After the Petition
for bankruptcy is filed, you do not directly pay any creditors who
are listed in the Chapter 13 Plan. The Trustee will pay the attorney,
and the Court can approve any additional attorney's fees.
E. You
must make your first payment within 25 days of the
date of filing of your petition.
F. Any
payments not deducted from your paycheck must be
paid by you to the Trustee whenever it is due, even
before your plan is confirmed.
II. Approximately one week
after the filing date, the Trustee will begin to send out letters
that you will receive. You should read these letters over carefully.
One of the letters will be an order directing your employer to withhold
the plan payment from your wages. Make sure that this plan payment
is the correct amount and for the correct time period. If not, contact
us or the Chapter 13 Trustee to have it corrected. You will also
receive an order from the Court setting your creditor's meeting.
This will be a piece of paper with many boxes but which will list
your Bankruptcy number and the date, time, and place of your creditors'
meeting.
Call
901-757-5557 for a free appointment to discuss your situation.
III. CREDITORS' MEETING
Approximately, three weeks after you receive
the notice from the Court and four weeks after the filing of your
bankruptcy, there will be a Creditors' Meeting held at the Bankruptcy
Court. YOU MUST ATTEND OR YOUR CASE WILL BE DISMISSED.
Call our office: 1) if you do not receive notice of the
Creditors' Meeting within three weeks; or 2) if you cannot attend
the Creditors' Meeting. YOU WILL BE CHARGED AN
ADDITIONAL FEE IF THE LAWYER GOES TO THE CREDITORS' MEETING AND
YOU DO NOT APPEAR. You must attend
a Creditors' Meeting. You should arrive approximately ten minutes
early to the creditors' meeting. Have a seat in the creditors' meeting
hearing room. An attorney from THE COHN LAW FIRM will be present
to hear your case. If the hearing examiner or Trustee calls your
name or the attorney's name and he is not there, stand up and mention
to the examiner that we are arriving shortly. Many times we get
caught in another court and arrive late for a hearing. However,
we will try to avoid this situation.
The
Creditors' Meeting is not like a trial in which
Perry Mason is working. It is merely an informal
question and answer session. Creditors will want to
have the correct amount of payments and interest
rate in the Chapter 13 plan. They will ask you
questions about what happened to certain collateral
security or about your income or any other
financial information. You should be prepared to
answer these questions. If you have any questions,
you should contact us and discuss these matters
prior to the hearing. The vast majority of the
time, the questions asked are harmless and present
no problems to the Debtor.
A. If you do not
have any car INSURANCE and the Chapter 13 Trustee
will add collision coverage to protect any creditor whose debt is
secured by a vehicle. They will also raise your monthly payment to
cover the cost of the INSURANCE. Therefore, if you have car INSURANCE,
you must have evidence of the INSURANCE policy and that you have paid
the premium on the policy. You must bring
a copy of the policy and a paid receipt showing that you have car
(collision) INSURANCE to the Creditors' meeting in order to avoid
having the Trustee placing collision INSURANCE in your plan and raising
the plan payments which you must pay to the Trustee. We highly suggest
that you obtain your own INSURANCE which would include liability INSURANCE.
I think that you will find this to be much cheaper and more economical
than paying the Trustee's rates.
IV. CONFIRMATION HEARING
Two
weeks after the Creditors' Meeting there will be a
confirmation hearing. Your plan will be confirmed
and your Chapter 13 plan will continue to run for
the time period that your plan proposed if there
are no objections to the plan. Generally, there are
no objections to the plan. Under some
circumstances, a creditor will object to the
payment plan. If there is an objection filed, then
you must appear at the hearing and defend the
objection.
V. After the Chapter 13 plan is confirmed and your plan goes
into effect, several things may happen. For each of these things,
our contract with you states that these items will incur additional
attorney fees. We will bill you by the hour, or in advance, for additional
items. If you do not have the money to pay these fees, with your approval,
we will file a proof of claim with the Trustee and be paid through
your plan.
A. If
you have failed to make certain payments, a secured
creditor may ask the Court to lift the automatic
injunction to allow them to repossess an item such
as a car or to foreclose on real property such as a
house or building. Obviously this is not part of
getting your plan implemented, so we must charge
you an additional amount.
B. Motion to Amend
If you leave off
creditors or you fail to tell us about creditors, then add a creditor
later, requires an additional proceeding. There is a $20.00 filing
fee plus an attorney fee.
The filing fee
goes to the Court. You must pay to us the filing fee before the
motion to amend can be filed.
C. Trustee's Motion to
Dismiss or Convert
If you fail to make your Chapter 13 plan payments the Chapter 13
trustee will seek to have your plan dismissed or converted to a
straight bankruptcy. Obviously this is something far different from
setting up your Chapter 13 plan and implementing it. This would
require additional attorney's work and additional billing by the
attorney. You must appear at the Court for this motion. The Trustee
may schedule an 8:30 am hearing. You must attend, but your attorney
will not.
D. If you are hurt or
laid off and cannot work, your payments must still be made. You
should double up your payments to the Chapter 13 Trustee
to make up for any missed payments. Your payments
cannot be reduced lower than the amount of your house
note. Your house note cannot be reduced, and must
be paid every month.
E. There are various
other Motions which can be filed and which address select situations.
Call
901-757-5557 for a free appointment to discuss your situation.
IV. HOUSE MORTGAGE
SITUATIONS
If your house mortgage
payments are placed in the Chapter 13 plan, you will not have to
pay your mortgage payments directly to the mortgage company so long
as the plan is in effect. They will come out of your check or be
included in your payment to the trustee. Your payments should be
made to the Chapter 13 Trustee by the 5th of each month. However,
when your plan is finished paying out, you will have to resume your
payments directly to the mortgage company.
You should also make
sure that the proper amount of the house note is being paid by your
Chapter 13 Trustee. This means you should make sure that the correct
amount of insurance and tax payments are included in the note. Otherwise,
you will have a large amount of money still owed to the Mortgage
company when your plan is finished.
If you wish to
sell your house, or any personal property which has a mortgage,
contact your lawyer as we must file a Motion to obtain approval of
the Court.
VII. "In order to play, you
must pay...". ALL payments to the Chapter 13 Trustee MUST be paid.
There are no excuses. If your employer does
not deduct the payments from your check, then you must make the payments
directly to the Trustee. If your plan is dismissed, save the money
which would go for payments, as you will have to pay ALL past due
payments when the plan is reinstated. Make sure your employer is sending
to the Trustee the payments which he is deducting from your check.
If not, let the Trustee and our Law Firm know immediately.
If you
get behind in payments to the Trustee-Trustee must
pay additional interest to secured creditors
THIS WILL RAISE
YOUR PAYMENTS TO THE TRUSTEE
It is therefore very
important that you make your payment ON TIME to the Trustee. If
you do get behind, such as being ill, injured, or laid off, you
should increase your payments once you return to work in order to
bring them current as soon as possible and reduce the increase in
your payment.
Questions about payments should be
directed to the Chapter 13 Trustee or our office.
VIII. Your payments
to the Chapter 13 Trustee may go up after the
Creditor's Meeting for the following reasons:
1.
Your house note may be increased because of an
increase in taxes and/or insurance.
2.
Unsecured Creditors may file large claims late,
after the Chapter 13 Trustee and set a percentage
paid to unsecured creditors. This means it will
take more money to pay these creditors. (You should
contact us to file a Motion to Reduce Percentage
Paid to Unsecured Creditors).
3.
Creditors who become Creditors after you file
Bankruptcy may file a proof of claim, such as the
IRS for taxes incurred after your plan is
confirmed.
4. The
Chapter 13 Trustee may determine through the use of
his computer that your payments should be higher in
order that your plan pay out within 60 months, or
because the Chapter 13 Trustee's computer says that
your plan payments allow you to pay a higher
percentage to unsecured creditors.
5. You may add pre-filing
creditors which you previously failed to include. The Court charges
a filing fee of $20.00 which must be paid before the motion
is filed.
6. your payments may
be suspended for 60 to 90 days. These payments must be made later.
The Trustee does this by adding on an additional amount to your
payments.
IX. After your
Chapter 13 plan has finished being paid out, you
will have paid all of your creditors in full. Any
secured creditors such as a car, furniture, or
jewelry whose loan was basically financed through
the Chapter 13 plan will convey you a good title to
the property at that time. Obviously if it is
furniture or jewelry, there will be no title.
However, if it is a car, mobile home, boat, or any
other such item, the creditor should convey to you
a certificate title free of any liens.
You
will no longer owe any of the unsecured debts which
were in the Chapter 13 plan.
The Chapter 13 Trustee is located at:
Chapter 13 Trustee
Suite
1113, 200 Jefferson Avenue
Memphis, Tennessee
38103-2352
Include your Bankruptcy Court Docket
Number on your check. Your payments should be mailed to that
address. The Trustee will not accept payments in person
at his office, nor will he accept payments in cash.
If you give him a check which bounces, you will then be required
to make all future payments with a cashier's check or money order.
Personal checks are not credited by the Chapter 13 Trustee until
they have the check on deposit for 45 days.
Call
901-757-5557 for a free appointment to discuss your situation.
X. TELEPHONE CALLS AND
APPOINTMENTS
The
attorney will be happy to answer your questions if
he/she is available. If not, the staff will answer
your questions, or, if they cannot, they will take
your question to the attorney and call you back
with an answer. Do not expect call backs from the
attorney. If you feel this is an important item,
call and make an appointment to talk to the
attorney. If you do not feel it is important enough
to make an appointment, then it is clearly not
important enough for a return call from an
attorney.
Return
to top of page.
|